Judge Acquits MIT Brothers in $25 Million Ethereum MEV Case, Saying the Trades Were Not Wire Fraud
Published November 17, 2026, 7:20 AM PKT. Based on reporting by The Block (primary source) and corroborating reporting by KuCoin News, drawing on Reuters (secondary source).
A Manhattan federal judge acquitted MIT-educated brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on Monday, November 16, 2026, of wire fraud and related charges over a $25 million Ethereum ($ETH) maximal extractable value, or MEV, exploit, ruling that their trading strategy did not constitute criminal fraud under the statutes prosecutors charged them with.
U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke granted the brothers' motion for acquittal, finding that prosecutors failed to show they made material misrepresentations in executing the scheme. The brothers used bait transactions to manipulate other traders' sandwich bots before intercepting their trades, but the judge said the transactions were not conducted on a regulated market where the alleged conduct would be prohibited. Clarke said the question was not whether the brothers' trading strategy was improper or unethical, but whether it constituted wire fraud.
The ruling ends a federal prosecution that began with the brothers' arrest and indictment in May 2024, in what prosecutors said was the first case of its kind ever brought in federal court. The first trial ended in November 2025 with a mistrial, after the jury deadlocked in Manhattan federal court.
The 12-second exploit that started the case
The case goes back to April 2023, when a group of MEV bots lost more than $25 million in about 12 seconds during a sophisticated attack on the Ethereum ($ETH) blockchain. The attacker replaced the normal MEV transactions of the bots with malicious ones, causing them to lose money. MEV is the maximum amount of value that can be extracted from a given DeFi protocol or smart contract by a user or group of users, and the bots in question were built to profit from it by reordering other people's trades.
Prosecutors said the brothers, both computer programmers, used deceptive trades to attract the trading bots and empty other cryptocurrency traders' accounts on Ethereum ($ETH). They said the brothers spent months planning to manipulate the protocols that determine which transactions enter the blockchain, and that they exploited a vulnerability in MEV-Boost software, which most Ethereum ($ETH) network validators use. Validators check that new transactions are valid before they are added to the blockchain.
Both brothers graduated from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and prosecutors said they acquired the skills behind the trading strategy at MIT. According to media reports, Anton earned a bachelor's degree in computer science and engineering in 2024, while James earned a bachelor's degree in 2019 and a master's degree in aeronautics in 2021. Defense lawyers maintained throughout that the brothers' trading strategy was lawful.
What the judge actually decided
Clarke's ruling turned on two points. First, the trial evidence did not establish any material misrepresentations by the brothers, which meant the wire fraud charges could not stand. Second, the transactions were not placed on a regulated market with rules prohibiting this conduct, so the legal theory prosecutors advanced did not fit the facts. The judge said the court was not deciding whether the brothers acted morally or committed offenses that prosecutors had not charged. The issue, she said, was whether the trial evidence, viewed most favorably to the government, supported convictions for wire fraud and related offenses. It did not.
That narrow framing is what makes the ruling significant. Clarke did not bless the strategy, and she did not rule that exploiting a software vulnerability is lawful in general. She ruled that this conduct, charged under these statutes, was not wire fraud. The distinction matters for every future case in which prosecutors try to fit blockchain trading into fraud laws written for regulated markets.
Coin Center, the crypto policy group, had criticized the prosecution from the start. Its executive director, Peter Van Valkenburgh, told The Block at the time of the mistrial that the case was a "massive overstep", and said a hung jury was not surprising because a juror without crypto knowledge would find the technical facts confusing. The brothers' lawyers offered no immediate comment after the acquittal, and a spokesperson for U.S. Attorney James McDonald, whose office handled the prosecution, declined to comment.
Why the ruling matters for crypto enforcement
The acquittal narrows how U.S. authorities can apply wire fraud statutes to trading strategies on decentralized blockchain networks. Prosecutors had argued that bait transactions designed to lure automated bots into a trap were fraud, even though every transaction was visible on a public ledger and no one misrepresented anything to a regulated exchange. The judge's answer was that fraud needs a misrepresentation and a market whose rules the conduct breaks, and this case had neither.
The decision is likely to shape how the Justice Department approaches future crypto market manipulation cases, especially where the conduct happens through public blockchain transactions rather than on regulated venues. It also draws a line that crypto developers and traders have been waiting for a court to draw: aggressive MEV strategies, however sharp, are not automatically criminal, and the government has to prove fraud under the statute it charges, not simply show that someone profited from a software bug.
The ruling does not legalize hacking or outright theft on Ethereum ($ETH). It decides one case, on one set of charges, under one statute. But it is the first time a federal judge has ruled on whether MEV exploitation is wire fraud, and the answer was no.
What happens next
The acquittal closes the prosecution that began in May 2024, and the brothers walk free after more than two years of facing charges that carried decades in prison. The open question now is whether the Justice Department changes how it charges blockchain trading cases, and whether other defendants in pending crypto market manipulation matters cite Clarke's reasoning. For the MEV ecosystem, the message is that the courts will judge the strategy on the law as written, not on how aggressive it looks.
This article is news reporting and is not investment advice.
Sources
- The Block, Peraire-Bueno brothers acquitted of wire fraud in $25 million Ethereum MEV case, November 16, 2026 (primary source: Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud and related charges, granting their motion for acquittal; prosecutors failed to show material misrepresentations; transactions were not conducted on a regulated market where the conduct would be prohibited; April 2023 attack cost MEV bots more than $25 million in seconds; brothers arrested May 2024; mistrial declared November 2025 after the jury deadlocked; Coin Center executive director Peter Van Valkenburgh called the case a "massive overstep")
- KuCoin News, US Judge Acquits MIT-Educated Brothers in $25M Crypto Theft Case, November 16, 2026 (secondary source, drawing on Reuters: theft completed within 12 seconds; Clarke ruled prosecutors had not established fraud by profiting from a software vulnerability; charges were a type of alleged fraud never previously brought to court; brothers spent months planning to manipulate transaction validation protocols; vulnerability in MEV-Boost software used by most Ethereum validators; both brothers MIT graduates, Anton with a bachelor's degree in computer science and engineering in 2024, James with a bachelor's degree in 2019 and a master's degree in aeronautics in 2021; lawyers offered no immediate comment; spokesperson for U.S. Attorney James McDonald declined to comment)
MABOnChain Daily Brief
The key crypto and markets stories in one short, plain-language email. Free. Unsubscribe any time.
Prefer chat? Join us on Telegram Watch on YouTube
Keep reading
Hackers Injected Crypto-Stealing Malware Into 178 Major Websites Through Optimizely
Attackers injected malicious JavaScript into Optimizely Web customer projects on November 16, 2026, serving a crypto clipper and card skimmer to visitors of 178 organisations including Ledger, the BBC, CNN, HSBC, Salesforce, Zoom, IKEA and Equifax. Researcher Amirul Iman dubbed the campaign Optimjack. Report URI found 188 infected scripts out of 1,611 checked. The payload swapped Bitcoin, Ether, Solana and other wallet addresses for attacker-controlled ones, skimmed card details, stole cookies and screenshots, and pushed Coruna and DarkSword iOS exploit kits to iPhones and iPads. About 7,040 dollars in crypto reached attacker wallets within nine hours. Optimizely said an unauthorised party exploited a vulnerability in its Experimentation account signup flow and that it has blocked the path, deployed a fix and removed the code. By 21:52 UTC, 187 of 188 infected files were clean. How the attackers got write access is still unknown.
Trezor Says Shipping Partner Breach Exposed Data From About 27,000 Orders
Trezor said on November 16, 2026 that a breach at Skladon, one of its shipping partners, exposed personal data tied to about 27,000 orders placed between August 9 and November 7, 2026, including names, phone numbers, delivery addresses and email addresses. Trezor said its own systems were not compromised and no wallet backups, PINs or passphrases were involved, but some affected customers have already reported scam calls. The company is rolling out anonymous pickup in 18 European countries and cutting order data retention from 90 days to 45 days. The breach is the third time this year a Trezor partner incident has exposed customer data, after breaches at ShipMonk and Brevo.
Backpack Wins CFTC Approval to Run the First Blockchain-Based Derivatives Exchange in the U.S.
Backpack said on November 16, 2026 that the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission approved its U.S. derivatives exchange and clearing operations, a Designated Contract Market designation for TLD Markets, Inc. on November 16 and a Derivatives Clearing Organization registration for TLD Clearing, Inc. on November 13. U.S. users will be able to trade leveraged crypto perpetual futures around the clock with fiat or crypto collateral, cross-margin and access to Backpack's global liquidity in one unified order book. No launch date was given. CFTC Chair Michael S. Selig called the approvals a milestone for blockchain-built market infrastructure, and Backpack, which serves users in more than 150 countries with over $450 billion in cumulative trading volume, describes the approval as the first of its kind in the United States.
Former Robinhood Engineer Pleads Guilty to Insider Trading on Confidential Crypto Listings
Former Robinhood software engineer Huaisong Xiang, 30, pleaded guilty to wire fraud in Manhattan federal court on November 16, 2026, admitting he used confidential information about upcoming Robinhood Crypto listings to trade perpetual futures on Hyperliquid. Prosecutors say he profited $125,523 between 2025 and 2026 by buying perpetuals tied to tokens including Popcat ($POPCAT), Cat in a Dogs World ($MEW), Moo Deng ($MOODENG), Ondo ($ONDO) and Render ($RENDER) before Robinhood announced the listings. He agreed to forfeit the profits, faces up to 20 years in prison, and is due to be sentenced on February 25, 2027. A second engineer, Hefu Chai, was charged in September and his case is still pending.



