Cboe and Citadel Securities Backed Group Sues CFTC Over Single-Stock Perpetual Approvals
Published November 4, 2026, 12:15 PM PKT. Based on the Capital Markets Alliance complaint filed November 3, 2026 (primary source, case 1:26-cv-09608), the CFTC chairman statement of November 3, 2026, and reporting of the filing by Reuters, Crypto Briefing, The Defiant and PrimeXBT (secondary sources). No court has ruled on the challenge yet.
The Capital Markets Alliance, an industry group backed by Cboe Global Markets, Citadel Securities and the Healthy Markets Association, sued the Commodity Futures Trading Commission on November 3, 2026, seeking to overturn the agency's approval of perpetual futures tied to individual stocks, Reuters reported. The lawsuit, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York the same day CFTC Chairman Michael S. Selig confirmed the products could begin trading, is the first court challenge to the equity perpetual clearance that MABOnChain reported on November 3, and it puts the newest corner of U.S. derivatives trading under immediate legal threat before a single contract has reportedly traded.
The lawsuit filed the same day as the approval
The alliance filed its complaint on Tuesday, November 3, hours after Selig announced that perpetual futures on individual equity securities could begin trading on qualifying U.S. exchanges, according to Reuters and Crypto Briefing. The suit targets approvals for three venues, Coinbase Derivatives, KalshiEX and Bitnomial Exchange, PrimeXBT reported, citing The Defiant. It asks the court to vacate the approvals, declare the covered products security-based swaps, and grant a temporary restraining order plus preliminary and permanent injunctions, along with a stay while the case proceeds. The requested injunction would also stop the CFTC from permitting the same contracts to be listed as security futures through an alternative route, including exchange self-certification, PrimeXBT reported. The case is docketed as Capital Markets Alliance Association v. Commodity Futures Trading Commission, 1:26-cv-09608, according to the public docket reviewed by The Crypto Guide, which noted that the docket showed a request for emergency relief but no order granting it.
Swaps or futures: the jurisdiction fight
The core argument is a classification dispute with a regulator attached to each side. The alliance argues that perpetual contracts tied to individual stocks are security-based swaps, which fall under the Securities and Exchange Commission's exclusive jurisdiction, because they have no expiration date and no future-delivery obligation, PrimeXBT reported. Under that reading, the CFTC had no authority to approve them unilaterally, and the approval invited what the complaint called a parallel, synthetic market in U.S. stocks to grow outside the SEC's exclusive jurisdiction, Reuters reported. Selig's statement took the opposite position: the contracts are security futures products under the Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000, deemed approved under CFTC Regulation 40.3, and subject to oversight by both the CFTC and the SEC, with eligible venues required to be notice-registered with the SEC to trade them. The products give traders leveraged exposure to stock price moves without owning the shares and without the expiration dates of traditional futures, Crypto Briefing reported, and the CFTC said bringing them onto regulated U.S. exchanges would offer an alternative to offshore trading platforms.
The 45-day clock that ran out
The challenge also attacks how the approval happened. The complaint targets product applications and related rule filings submitted on September 18, PrimeXBT reported, and says the CFTC's 45-day review period expired on November 2 without a rejection or an extension. Selig then confirmed on November 3 that the equity perps were deemed approved and could begin trading. The alliance says that sequence violated the Administrative Procedure Act, arguing the CFTC failed to explain its classification decision or adequately consider the impact on investors and securities markets, Crypto Briefing reported. Alliance secretary Adam Ford said the hasty rollout of financial products that circumvent well established regulatory frameworks erodes investor protection and undermines the integrity and resiliency of the American financial system, Crypto Briefing reported. A CFTC spokesperson called the lawsuit a troubling attempt to interfere with CFTC-regulated markets, Reuters reported.
A second front in the perps war
The suit opens a second front in a fight the CFTC is already defending. In June, CME Group sued the CFTC over its approval of crypto perpetual futures offered by Kalshi and Coinbase, Reuters reported, and that case is still running. The new challenge extends the same turf war from crypto perps to stock perps, and it arrives with heavyweight backing: Cboe operates options, futures, equities and clearing businesses, and Citadel Securities is one of the largest U.S. market makers, and both have a direct commercial interest in keeping stock-linked derivatives inside the registered securities framework, where their existing businesses sit. The alliance also says the new products threaten to divert customers, transactions and related revenue from its members' securities businesses, PrimeXBT reported. Separately, ICE and TradeXYZ announced on October 29 a plan for a U.S.-regulated perpetuals market built on Hyperliquid, but their plan was not among the three approvals the alliance challenges, and ICE says it still needs regulatory approvals, PrimeXBT reported.
What happens next
Nothing in the filing stops trading by itself. The alliance has asked for emergency relief, but no court order granting it had appeared on the public docket at the time of the reports reviewed, and a requested order is not a ruling. Two other clocks are still running alongside the case: the SEC has a 60-day window to abrogate the approvals, and no exchange has yet been reported to have executed a first single-stock perpetual trade. If the court grants the stay or injunction the alliance seeks, the November 3 clearance would be frozen before launch; if it does not, the first trades could land while the jurisdiction fight plays out. Either way, the November 3 approval is now contested in court on the day it was announced, and the question of whether a stock perpetual is a future or a swap will decide which regulator controls it. This article is news reporting and is not investment advice.
Sources
- Capital Markets Alliance, complaint filed November 3, 2026, Capital Markets Alliance Association v. Commodity Futures Trading Commission, 1:26-cv-09608 (S.D.N.Y.), primary source: vacatur request, declaration that the products are security-based swaps, temporary restraining order, preliminary and permanent injunctions, stay, bar on self-certification route, September 18 applications, 45-day review expiry on November 2, Administrative Procedure Act claims, Adam Ford statement
- Reuters, Cboe, Citadel-backed group sues US regulator over single-stock perps (November 3, 2026, secondary source: filing date and court, Capital Markets Alliance members, security-based swap argument, parallel synthetic market claim, CFTC spokesperson troubling interference comment, CME June lawsuit over crypto perps)
- Crypto Briefing, Cboe and Citadel backed group sues CFTC over US stock perpetual futures approval (November 3, 2026, secondary source: filing and venue, vacatur and trading block sought, SEC exclusive jurisdiction argument, Administrative Procedure Act claim, Adam Ford quote, Selig security futures position, CFTC offshore alternative rationale, CME June lawsuit)
- PrimeXBT, Cboe-Backed Group Sues CFTC to Overturn Single-Stock Perpetuals Approvals (November 3, 2026, secondary source: three challenged venues Coinbase Derivatives, KalshiEX and Bitnomial Exchange, case number, relief sought including self-certification bar, September 18 filings, November 2 review expiry, no-expiration and no-delivery swap argument, revenue diversion claim, ICE and TradeXYZ October 29 Hyperliquid plan not challenged)
- CFTC Chairman Michael S. Selig, statement on equity perpetual futures, November 3, 2026 (primary source via MABOnChain article 437: deemed approved under Regulation 40.3, security futures under the Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000, joint CFTC and SEC oversight, venues notice-registered with the SEC, no exchanges or stocks named, no first trade reported)
MABOnChain Daily Brief
The key crypto and markets stories in one short, plain-language email. Free. Unsubscribe any time.
Prefer chat? Join us on Telegram Watch on YouTube
Keep reading
Block Agrees in Principle to $764 Million DOJ Settlement Over Anti-Money-Laundering Program
Block, Inc. has agreed in principle to pay about $764 million to resolve a U.S. Justice Department investigation into its anti-money-laundering controls, the company disclosed in a November 3, 2026 SEC filing, under a proposed deferred prosecution agreement that would defer for three years a criminal charge alleging Block failed to maintain an effective anti-money-laundering program in violation of the Bank Secrecy Act. The proposed resolution carries a gross monetary component of about $964 million, reduced to $764 million after credits for earlier regulatory settlements, and Block said it has already accrued the net amount. The deal is not final: it remains subject to a final agreement and court approval, and Block warned the ultimate terms could result in losses exceeding the amount accrued. The same filing reported third quarter net income of $566 million on revenue of $6.72 billion, with bitcoin ecosystem gross profit down 50 percent to $52 million, which Block attributed primarily to lower fees on certain Cash App bitcoin transactions.
SEC Staff Calls Canton Coin a Digital Commodity in No-Action Letter, Clearing Its Programmatic Minting
Staff in the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission Division of Corporation Finance said on November 3, 2026 that it views Canton Coin (CC) as a digital commodity and will not recommend enforcement action if the coin is minted programmatically by Super Validators, Validators and application providers without registration under Section 5 of the Securities Act or Section 12(g) of the Exchange Act, in a no-action letter answering an October 30 request from Digital Asset Holdings, creator of the Canton protocol. The staff position rests on two representations, that CC derives its value from the programmatic operation of the Canton Network and supply and demand rather than expected profits from the essential managerial efforts of others, and that the network has no central party under the SEC March 2026 crypto asset interpretation. The letter is a staff enforcement position only, not a legal conclusion, a Commission vote, an approval or an endorsement.
Democrats Win U.S. Senate in 2026 Midterms, Completing Congress Sweep That Reshapes Crypto's Path
Democrats won control of the U.S. Senate in the 2026 midterm elections, Cointelegraph reported on November 4, 2026, citing the Associated Press, after Democrat Josh Turek won Iowa's open Senate seat and brought Democrats and independents who caucus with them to 51 seats. The Senate result completes a Democratic sweep of Congress hours after multiple decision desks projected Democrats would win the House (MABOnChain, article 441), and it reshapes the outlook for the stalled CLARITY Act market-structure bill, which failed a Senate procedural vote 49 to 50 on September 15, 2026, and must pass by January or start again from scratch in the next Congress. Bitcoin slid as much as 2.8 percent to $75,630.57 in Asia trading on November 4, its lowest since September 17, as early results pointed to the sweep, Bloomberg reported. Results are calls and projections based on counted votes, not certified results.
Zcash Rebounds 6% as NU7 Upgrade Nears After November 3 Washout
Zcash (ZEC) traded at about $1,208 on November 4, 2026, up about 6.2 percent in 24 hours on CoinGecko, with a market capitalization of about $20.6 billion and 24-hour trading volume near $961 million, rebounding a day after an 11 percent drop to about $1,135 on November 3 that market reports tied to the forced closure of a leveraged whale position. The Network Upgrade 7 (NU7) upgrade, which would cut Zcash block times from 75 seconds to 25 seconds, is expected around November 5 at block 3,543,405 according to market reports, while a dispute over the Zcash Community Grants pool, about 98,000 ZEC worth roughly $124 million, remains unresolved days before activation. ZEC is still down about 9.6 percent over seven days and about 11.5 percent over 30 days on CoinGecko, and sits about 62 percent below its all-time high of $3,191.93.