44 Attorneys General Challenge CFTC Rules That Would Put Prediction Markets Under Federal Control
Published November 22, 2026, 9:50 AM PKT. Based on the New Jersey Office of the Attorney General release, and on reporting by CDC Gaming. The coalition's comment letters were announced on November 20, 2026.
Forty-four state attorneys general have gone after the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's bid to take sole control of prediction markets. The bipartisan coalition, co-led by New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport, filed comment letters this week opposing two federal rules that would treat sports wagering, election betting and similar wagers on prediction markets as swaps under federal law, according to the New Jersey Office of the Attorney General. If the rules stand, the states say, platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket could run sports and election betting nationwide without complying with any state's gambling laws.
Two rules, one word: swaps
Both rules turn on a single legal word. The CFTC regulates financial markets where traders buy and sell contracts tied to the future price of things like oil, wheat, interest rates and foreign currency, including certain swaps, according to the New Jersey release. The agency has not traditionally regulated gambling or contracts used for entertainment rather than financial risk management. The two rules would change what counts as a swap so that sports and election bets fall inside the CFTC's remit, which the agency argues displaces state control.
The first rule is an interim rule that is already in effect. It draws a line between house-backed casino style games and games where bettors wager against each other, and only the house-backed games count as traditional gambling products that are not swaps, according to the release. The second rule is a proposal, not yet in effect, that would expand the definition of swap to include peer-to-peer sports and election betting. The CFTC released that proposal on October 9, 2026, with the stated goal of resolving ambiguity over whether contracts tied to sports, politics, culture and weather are financial instruments, according to CDC Gaming. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig believes these products are commodity derivatives squarely within the agency's regulatory remit and exclusive jurisdiction, according to CDC Gaming.
What the states told the CFTC
The coalition's objection is blunt. "The CFTC continues to stray far outside of its lane by seeking to exclusively regulate certain forms of sports gambling on prediction markets," Davenport said in the release. "These actions seek to override states' longstanding authority to regulate gambling within our borders, which would allow prediction markets to operate without complying with state gambling regulations and safeguards to ensure responsible gaming."
The letters make three arguments, according to the release. First, regulating gambling and protecting residents from its harms falls within the states' traditional police powers, and the CFTC has no legal power to address gambling harms. Second, the CFTC skipped required steps in writing the rules. Third, the agency went beyond the rulemaking power Congress gave it. Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson, who co-led the coalition, put the point more colorfully, according to CDC Gaming: "A sports bet isn't a derivative just because the CFTC says so," the letter reads. "If Congress wanted the commission running sports gambling, it would have said so, and headquartered it in Las Vegas."
The states also warn of a practical consequence. Prediction markets let users wager on sporting events much like traditional sportsbooks, but without the same state oversight, and the proposed rule could let traditional sportsbooks reorganize as prediction markets to sidestep licensing requirements, age restrictions and problem-gambling protections, according to CDC Gaming.
A quorum question, and a court split
The coalition added a procedural challenge. The attorneys general question the agency's ability to adopt the rule with only one commissioner currently serving, arguing that it lacks the required quorum, according to CDC Gaming. The CFTC is designed for five commissioners and has been operating short-staffed.
The courts, meanwhile, are split on the underlying question. A divided U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 in Maryland's favor, denying Kalshi's appeal and allowing gaming regulators to pursue enforcement actions against the platform for permitting sports-event contracts without a license, according to CDC Gaming. The Ninth and Sixth Circuits have also ruled against Kalshi, while the Third Circuit delivered Kalshi's only win, ruling that New Jersey gaming regulators could not ban sports-event contracts. Kalshi called the Fourth Circuit decision a splintered one with three separate contradictory opinions, and said it shows there is no unified legal argument against prediction markets, according to CDC Gaming.
New Jersey has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to hear its case against Kalshi, with the support of 39 states and the District of Columbia, along with 146 tribal nations and tribal organizations, according to the New Jersey release. The release says the majority of federal courts to have addressed the issue have rejected the conclusion that prediction markets allowing sports betting are exempt from state law.
The fight lands the same week as the New York hearing
The coalition's letters arrive in the middle of a fast-moving week for prediction markets. New York Attorney General Letitia James refiled a proposed motion for a temporary restraining order on Friday, seeking to immediately prohibit Kalshi from offering sports, culture, election and other contracts within New York, according to CDC Gaming. A New York judge will hear that request on Monday, November 23, 2026, at 11:30 a.m. ET, in a hearing Kalshi says could shut down its exchange for every customer, everywhere. A federal judge on Friday rejected the CFTC's second emergency bid to block the state case, clearing the way for the state court to decide.
Congress is moving on the same front. The Senate passed the DEATH BETS Act on November 20, 2026, to ban war and death wagers on prediction markets, and a House bill would create a Justice Department whistleblower program for insider trading on prediction markets. The attorneys general letters do not settle anything on their own: they are comments on rules, one in effect and one proposed, and the CFTC has given no public response to them as of this writing. But 44 attorneys general, from both parties, now stand on the record saying the federal agency is claiming a power Congress never gave it, and the Supreme Court petition and the Monday hearing in New York will decide how much of that fight the states can win in court.
This article is news reporting and is not investment advice.
Sources
- New Jersey Office of the Attorney General, Attorney General Davenport, Multistate Coalition Oppose CFTC Rulemakings on Gambling Products and Prediction Markets, November 2026 (primary source: Attorney General Jennifer Davenport co-led a bipartisan coalition of 44 attorneys general opposing two federal rules that would allow sports wagering, election betting and similar gambling on prediction markets to be solely regulated by the CFTC, overriding states' traditional authority; the CFTC regulates financial markets including certain swaps and has not traditionally regulated gambling; the first rule is an interim rule currently in effect distinguishing house-backed casino style games from peer-to-peer wagers; the second is a proposal, not yet in effect, expanding the definition of swap to include sports and election betting; in comment letters filed this week the coalition said gambling regulation falls within the states' traditional police powers, the CFTC has no legal power to address gambling harms, and the CFTC skipped required steps and went beyond the rulemaking power Congress gave it; New Jersey has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to hear its case against Kalshi, with the support of 39 states and the District of Columbia and 146 tribal nations and tribal organizations; the majority of federal courts to have addressed the issue have rejected the conclusion that prediction markets allowing sports betting are exempt from state law)
- CDC Gaming, CDC Gaming: Inside the latest prediction market news, November 20, 2026 (secondary source: Attorney General Letitia James refiled a proposed motion for a temporary restraining order on Friday seeking to prohibit Kalshi from offering sports, culture, election and other contracts within New York, and to prohibit sales to anyone under 21; the CFTC released the swap proposal on October 9, 2026, to expand the definition of swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act to include contracts tied to sports, politics, culture and weather; CFTC Chairman Michael Selig believes these products are commodity derivatives within the agency's exclusive jurisdiction; the coalition letter says "A sports bet isn't a derivative just because the CFTC says so" and quotes Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson saying "If Congress wanted the commission running sports gambling, it would have said so, and headquartered it in Las Vegas"; the coalition challenges the agency's ability to adopt the rule with only one commissioner serving, arguing it lacks the required quorum; the letter warns traditional sportsbooks could reorganize as prediction markets to sidestep state gambling laws; a divided Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 in Maryland's favor, denying Kalshi's appeal; the Ninth and Sixth Circuits ruled against Kalshi while the Third Circuit ruled in Kalshi's favor; Kalshi said the Fourth Circuit decision had three separate contradictory opinions)
- MABOnChain, Kalshi Faces Monday Hearing on New York Order It Says Would Shut Down Its Exchange Nationwide, November 22, 2026 (secondary source: a New York judge will hear Attorney General Letitia James's request on Monday, November 23, 2026, for a temporary restraining order against Kalshi at 11:30 a.m. ET; a federal judge on Friday rejected the CFTC's second emergency bid to block the state case)
- MABOnChain, Senate Passes DEATH BETS Act to Ban War and Death Wagers on Prediction Markets, November 20, 2026 (secondary source: the Senate passed the DEATH BETS Act on November 20, 2026)
- MABOnChain, House Bill Would Create DOJ Whistleblower Program for Prediction Market Insider Trading, November 21, 2026 (secondary source: a House bill would create a Justice Department whistleblower program for insider trading on prediction markets)
MABOnChain Daily Brief
The key crypto and markets stories in one short, plain-language email. Free. Unsubscribe any time.
Prefer chat? Join us on Telegram Watch on YouTube
Keep reading
Chainflip Says Vault Theft Also Took 122.86 Bitcoin ($BTC), Offers Attacker 10% to Return the Rest
Chainflip said on November 21, 2026, that the theft from its vaults also took 122.86 Bitcoin ($BTC), lifting the combined haul to about $12 million, and offered the holder a 10 percent bounty to return 90 percent of the funds by 18:38 UTC on November 23. The protocol says it traced the attack to Tornado Cash funding on November 11, a FLIP purchase and a validator account registered the day before the drain, and has reported the theft to law enforcement.
ARK Withdraws Two CoinDesk 20 Crypto ETFs From the SEC Before Either One Launched
ARK Investment Management asked the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission on November 20, 2026, to withdraw the registration statements for its ARK CoinDesk 20 Crypto ETF and its ex-Bitcoin version, ten months after filing them. Neither fund ever became effective or sold a share, and ARK gave no reason beyond saying it does not intend to proceed. Its existing spot Bitcoin ($BTC) ETF is unaffected.
Kalshi Faces Monday Hearing on New York Order It Says Would Shut Down Its Exchange Nationwide
A New York judge will hear Attorney General Letitia James's request on Monday, November 23, 2026, for a temporary restraining order against Kalshi that the prediction market says would shut down its exchange for every customer, everywhere. A federal judge on Friday rejected the CFTC's second emergency bid to block the state case, clearing the way for the state court to decide at 11:30 a.m. ET.
Cyber ($CYBER) Bridge Exploit Mints 5.21 Million Unbacked Tokens as Upbit and Bithumb Freeze Transfers
Cyber ($CYBER) said it is investigating the unexpected minting of 5.21 million CYBER tokens on Solana ($SOL) on November 21, 2026, after the same amount drained from its Ethereum bridge contract and was sold for about $968,000 in Ether ($ETH). South Korea's Upbit and Bithumb suspended CYBER deposits and withdrawals within hours, and the token fell about 8 percent before recovering.


