MABOnChain
Educational content only. Nothing on this site is financial advice.
Home / Regulation / US Judge Rejects CFTC Bid to Block New York From Policing Kalshi
Regulation

US Judge Rejects CFTC Bid to Block New York From Policing Kalshi

By MABOnChain Desk · Published · Updated · 4 min read

Editorial digital-art illustration in the CoinTelegraph style: a grand federal courthouse in New York at dusk, its stone columns towering over a busy prediction-market trading floor, a giant wooden judge gavel striking down in the foreground with golden scales of justice beside it, glowing event-contract ticker boards showing red and green probability bars floating above silhouetted traders, the Manhattan skyline behind, deep charcoal and navy tones with gold and electric blue highlights, dramatic comic-book ink shading, halftone dots, cinematic painterly lighting, 16:9 wide composition, no text, no logos, no numbers, no identifiable faces.

Published November 21, 2026, 7:15 AM PKT. Based on Reuters reporting on November 20, 2026, CoinDesk reporting on November 18, 2026, and Covers reporting on November 18, 2026.

A federal judge in Manhattan on Friday, November 20, 2026, rejected the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission's emergency request to stop New York Attorney General Letitia James from pursuing an enforcement case against prediction market operator Kalshi. U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield said the regulator had "not established a likelihood of success on the merits" of its argument that federal law preempts states from enforcing their own gambling laws against prediction market operators, including requirements that operators obtain gaming licenses, Reuters reported. The CFTC did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The ruling came one day after U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick granted New York's request to move its lawsuit against Kalshi back to Manhattan state court, where it was filed on July 31. That move prompted the CFTC to ask for a late-afternoon emergency hearing to temporarily halt New York's enforcement activity. The regulator told the court that sending the case back to state court left "no practical barrier to New York moving full steam ahead" against Kalshi. Schofield's denial means New York can now press its case in state court while the wider fight over who regulates prediction markets continues in courts across the country.

Three appeals courts for the states, one for Kalshi

Schofield noted that three federal appeals courts have ruled that states may regulate Kalshi, while a fourth said New Jersey could not, Reuters reported. That split increases the likelihood that the U.S. Supreme Court will eventually decide the issue, the judge said. The Third Circuit ruled in Kalshi's favor on New Jersey, while appeals courts siding with the states have now ruled in cases covering Nevada, Michigan and Maryland. The disagreement runs deeper than the circuit split: in Maryland, the two judges who ruled against Kalshi reached the same result for different reasons, and the third judge dissented.

The stakes reach beyond Kalshi. The CFTC regards Kalshi's contracts as swaps and has sued 12 states to defend what it calls its exclusive jurisdiction over U.S. derivatives markets. If the Supreme Court takes the question up, its answer will set the rules for every prediction market operating in the United States, including Polymarket and the event-contract platforms that Coinbase and others are building. Until then, the map stays fractured: in some states the platforms trade freely, in others they face licensing demands, geoblocks or criminal charges.

The Maryland decision that widened the split

Three days before Schofield's ruling, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 on November 17 that Maryland may keep enforcing its sports wagering laws against Kalshi, in KalshiEX v. Martin, No. 25-1892. The court affirmed a lower court decision from August 2025, when U.S. District Judge Adam B. Abelson denied Kalshi's request for a preliminary injunction. Judge Roger Gregory wrote that regulation of gambling has long been a matter of traditional state police power, and he would not infer that Congress displaced Maryland's concurrent authority absent a clear expression of its intent to do so. Judge Stephanie Thacker went further, writing that sports event contracts are not swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act and therefore fall outside the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction. Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented, saying the contracts are swaps and that Congress gave the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over them.

Kalshi said the decision "demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets." Jeremy Baker, acting director of the Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Commission, welcomed the ruling, saying it affirmed the state's ability to regulate what is clearly sports wagering. The ruling also matters for the states around Maryland: North Carolina, Virginia and West Virginia already run regulated sports betting markets, and the decision could encourage their regulators to act. Washington has already obtained a state court order requiring Kalshi to restrict sports and other event contracts, including geolocation controls, and a temporary ban is in effect in Louisiana.

New York's case, and why the remand forced the emergency bid

James sued Kalshi on July 31, alleging the company should have obtained a license from the New York State Gaming Commission to operate a platform where people trade on the predicted outcomes of sports, elections and other events. She said such platforms can encourage problem gambling and endanger people's financial, emotional and physical health. New York's case is one of the oldest state actions against a prediction market, and its return to state court is what forced the CFTC's hand: once Broderick sent the case back on November 19, the regulator had no federal judge left between James and Kalshi, and it asked Schofield for an emergency order the same day. Schofield heard the request late Friday afternoon and denied it. Nothing in Friday's ruling decides whether Kalshi broke New York law. It decides only that the CFTC could not stop the state from trying to prove it.

Utah, the geoblock clock and the Senate

The New York ruling is one front in a wider legal war. In Utah, U.S. District Judge Robert J. Shelby heard the CFTC's request for a temporary restraining order against the state's criminal and civil cases against Kalshi on Friday afternoon, November 20, and no ruling had been reported by publication time. Utah filed criminal charges against Kalshi and its co-founders, and the CFTC sued Utah on October 26, arguing the Commodity Exchange Act preempts the state's gambling laws. MABOnChain reported the Utah suit when it was filed. The CFTC has also told its regulated exchanges, including Kalshi, to drop state geoblocks within 30 days, a demand issued on November 7 that expires in early December. And the U.S. Senate passed the DEATH BETS Act on November 20, a bill that would ban prediction market contracts tied to war and death, which MABOnChain reported the same day. The courts, the regulator and Congress are now all moving on prediction markets at once, and the Supreme Court may be the next stop. MABOnChain will keep tracking the Utah ruling, the geoblock deadline and any Supreme Court petition.

This article is news reporting and is not investment advice.

Sources

  • Reuters, via SRN News, US judge rejects CFTC emergency bid to block New York from policing Kalshi, November 20, 2026 (primary source: Judge Lorna Schofield rejecting the CFTC's emergency request, "not established a likelihood of success on the merits", three federal appeals courts ruling states may regulate Kalshi while a fourth said New Jersey could not, Judge Vernon Broderick sending the case back to Manhattan state court on November 19, the July 31 filing date, Attorney General Letitia James alleging Kalshi should have obtained a New York State Gaming Commission license, the CFTC regarding Kalshi's contracts as swaps and having sued 12 states, and the "no practical barrier to New York moving full steam ahead" warning)
  • CoinDesk, Another U.S. appellate court goes against Kalshi, building the industry's legal headwinds, November 18, 2026 (secondary source: the Fourth Circuit 2-1 ruling on November 17, Judge Roger Gregory's opinion on traditional state police power over gambling, Judge Stephanie Thacker's view that sports event contracts are not swaps, and the CFTC's 30-day demand that regulated exchanges return to offering contracts in all 50 states)
  • Covers, Maryland Moves Closer to Prediction Market Ban After Court Ruling, November 18, 2026 (secondary source: KalshiEX v. Martin, No. 25-1892, the August 2025 denial of a preliminary injunction by Judge Adam B. Abelson, Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin's dissent, Jeremy Baker's statement welcoming the ruling, three appeals courts ruling against Kalshi and the Third Circuit ruling in its favor on New Jersey, and state actions in Washington, Nevada, Michigan, Louisiana and Utah)
Not financial advice. This content is for information and education only. See our disclaimer, editorial policy and disclosures.

MABOnChain Daily Brief

The key crypto and markets stories in one short, plain-language email. Free. Unsubscribe any time.

Loading the signup form…

Prefer chat? Join us on Telegram Watch on YouTube

Keep reading

Markets

Nvidia Shares Crash 13% to a 52-Week Low as SEC Examines Its Accounting, Reuters Reports

2026-11-20 · 5 min read

Reuters reported on November 20, 2026 that SEC enforcement staff are examining potential accounting issues at Nvidia, citing two people briefed on the matter. Shares fell about 13 percent to a 52-week low of $126.64, erasing roughly $500 billion in market value in a single session, according to Barron's. The probe widens a civil investigation the Wall Street Journal first reported on November 17, and scrutiny has fallen on Nvidia's Singapore revenue reporting, where the Financial Times reported $104 billion was booked in 2025, nearly half of global sales.

Markets

Bitcoin Falls Below $60,000 for First Time Since July as $1.57 Billion in Crypto Positions Liquidate

2026-11-20 · 5 min read

Bitcoin ($BTC) fell below $60,000 on November 20, 2026, for the first time since July 2, trading near $58,500 late in the day after an intraday low near $57,800 on Binance. Ethereum ($ETH) broke $1,700, Solana ($SOL) fell below $70, and CoinGlass counted $1.57 billion in liquidations in 24 hours, mostly long positions. BlackRock's IBIT posted a record $541.1 million outflow on November 19, total spot Bitcoin ETF outflows reached $582.3 million that day and about $3.47 billion in November, the Crypto Fear and Greed Index read 12, and Bitcoin is on course for a seventh straight weekly loss.

Markets

Binance Hack Laundering Ramps Up as $149 Million in Bitcoin Flows Through Coinjoins, Elliptic Says

2026-11-20 · 4 min read

Blockchain analytics firm Elliptic said in a November 20, 2026 update that at least 2,310 Bitcoin, worth about $149 million, tied to the October 29 Binance theft has been pushed through coinjoin mixing transactions, with roughly 90 percent of the mixing happening since November 17. About 488,000 Ether, worth about $860 million, has moved out of five of the nine largest theft-linked wallets since November 17, and about $594 million in Ether moved across November 19 and 20, mostly through THORChain. About $2.35 billion remains in theft-linked wallets and about $2.85 billion is frozen, with very little cashed out so far.

Regulation

Hong Kong Gazettes Crypto Licensing Bill for Dealers, Advisers, Asset Managers and Custodians

2026-11-20 · 4 min read

Hong Kong published the Virtual Asset Services Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2026 in the Gazette on November 20, 2026, proposing to pull crypto dealing, advisory, management and custody services into a licensing regime run by the Securities and Futures Commission. The bill amends the Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorist Financing Ordinance, would require banks and stored value facility operators to register with the SFC before offering the covered services, and goes to the Legislative Council for its first reading on December 2, 2026.